Southern Girl Crime Stories

5 Solved True Crime Cases #441

🕒 Case Lineup 🔹 Hanna Marie Mack – A joyful 6-year-old girl from Navarro County, Texas, who was brutally murdered in 2007. DNA evidence later led to Shaun Arender, who implicated Kevin Anders in the crime. Despite chilling testimony, Anders was never charged with murder. 🔹 Henry X. Smith – A 43-year-old man from Laurel, Indiana, killed in the 2011 “Laurel Five” murders while trying to save a child. He was posthumously hailed as a hero, though his grave remains unmarked. The killer, David Ison, is serving life without parole. 🔹 James Lee Appleton – A former Arkansas church deacon murdered in 2017 by ex-police chief Grant Hardin. Hardin was convicted and later linked to a 1997 rape case. In 2025, he escaped prison and was recaptured 13 days later. 🔹 Louisa Dunne – A 75-year-old widow from Bristol, England, raped and murdered in her home in 1967. The case was solved in 2025 using forensic DNA and palm print evidence, leading to the conviction of 92-year-old Ryland Headley. 🔹 Steven Kilwein – A beloved family man and retired contractor murdered in Bozeman, Montana in 2021. After years of investigation, Austin Clowes was arrested in 2024. The case is set for trial in July 2025.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/65317db3
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 True Crime Cases Still Unsolved in 2025 #440

🕒 Case Lineup – 5 Chilling True Crime Stories Each one is a haunting mystery with heartbreaking details and unanswered questions. 🔹 Adrian Demont Washington (2012): A devoted husband and father vanishes without a trace after visiting the gym and dry cleaner in Austin, Texas. 🔹 Chase Allen Lackey (2017): A beloved athlete and dog owner disappears along with his pup, Champ. His belongings were left behind, but disturbing clues suggest foul play. 🔹 Chenell Renee Gilbert (2020): A mother and new grandmother never returns after visiting her ex-boyfriend’s home. Police delayed searching the property—and years later, the case remains unsolved. 🔹 Ebonee Shanetta Spears (2016): A young mom battling lupus and mental health challenges disappears after visiting the police station twice in two days. The last confirmed sighting was near her home. 🔹 Taprice Jaree Goodwin & Ariana Middlebrook (2020): Two young women, best friends and cousins, are gunned down in a running car just before dawn. Surveillance captured suspects—yet no arrests have been made.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/676c1085
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 Solved True Crime Cases #439

🕒 Case Lineup 🔹 Kristi Johnson – Lured by a fake Bond girl audition, Kristi’s dream turned into a nightmare at the hands of a predator. 🔹 Marcus "MJ" Daniels Jr. – A beloved college football player executed outside his home; four teens have now been sentenced. 🔹 Morgan Dana Harrington – Disappeared from a Metallica concert; years later, DNA linked her murder to a serial predator. 🔹 Sarah Everard – Kidnapped by a serving police officer while walking home; her case ignited a national reckoning in the UK. 🔹 Susan Elizabeth Mauldin – Murdered by a contractor she planned to confront; her remains were recovered from a landfill after a massive search effort.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/bc1fe588
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 True Crime Cases Still Unsolved in 2025 #438

🕒 Case Lineup – 5 Chilling True Crime Stories Each one is a haunting mystery with heartbreaking details and unanswered questions. 🔹 Abigail “Abby” Andrews – A pregnant Métis woman disappears in British Columbia in 2010 under suspicious circumstances involving a married man. 🔹 Gregory Keith Mann Jr. – A 20-year-old Texas man vanishes in 1997 after a mysterious late-night meeting. 🔹 Hollynn Snapp – A vulnerable 19-year-old goes missing in 2023 after being seen with an older man accused of severe abuse. 🔹 Opal Jo Dace Jennings – A 6-year-old girl abducted in 1999 in broad daylight; years later, her remains are found, but questions linger. 🔹 Tyler Andrew Stice – A quiet 20-year-old Arizona man disappears in 2016, leaving behind a clean car, a missing rifle, and a trail of disturbing clues.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/82c46923
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 Solved True Crime Cases #437

🕒 Case Lineup: 🔹 Angie Marie Housman (1993, Missouri): A trusting 9-year-old girl abducted just steps from home and found tortured and frozen days later. DNA would crack the case 26 years later. 🔹 Ashley Ann Carlson (1999, Oregon): A 7-year-old girl murdered by a teen neighbor who later helped search for her. Now, decades later, her killer seeks clemency under juvenile justice reforms. 🔹 Danielle Adeline Houchins (1996, Montana): A 15-year-old found drowned in shallow water. Ruled undetermined for decades—until DNA from a single hair led to her killer in 2024. 🔹 Kenneth Elton Herring (2019, Georgia): A diabetic episode led to confusion, a mistaken pursuit, and a fatal confrontation that ended his life and sent a young woman to prison for decades. 🔹 Sade Carleena Robinson (2024, Wisconsin): A 19-year-old college student’s first date turned into a horror story. Dismembered remains, digital footprints, and chilling evidence led to justice.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/a91e2384
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 True Crime Cases Still Unsolved in 2025 #436

🕒 Case Lineup – 5 Chilling True Crime Stories Each one is a haunting mystery with heartbreaking details and unanswered questions. 🔹 Armani Dante Morgan – A bold, openly gay 17-year-old targeted and murdered in Dallas in 2017. Despite harassment, assault, and threats leading up to his disappearance, no one has been held accountable. 🔹 Cheryl Anne Pyne – A 27-year-old woman murdered and dismembered in 2004. Though her killer confessed, Cheryl's remains went unidentified for eight years. Her mother was also murdered in 2005—and that case remains unsolved. 🔹 Debra Sue Daniel – Last seen in 2022 entering the woods of Crawford County, Pennsylvania with a known male companion. Her case was reclassified as a homicide in 2025, but she has never been found. 🔹 Pamela Rae Hinrichs – A 19-year-old bartender shot and killed in Clinton, Iowa during a robbery in 1981. Despite strong community suspicions and a similar killing nearby months later, her murder remains unsolved. 🔹 Patricia Kathleen McGlone (Midtown Jane Doe) – For 50 years, she was a nameless girl encased in concrete beneath a Manhattan nightclub. In 2024, DNA finally revealed her identity and exposed a twisted web of secrets from 1969.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/766ec0ed
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 Solved True Crime Cases #435

🕒 Case Lineup: 🔹 Brooke Carol Wilberger – A 19-year-old college student abducted in broad daylight from an apartment complex in Corvallis, Oregon. Ten months later, a daring escape by another woman in New Mexico would unravel the truth. 🔹 Deroshia “Pat” Matthews & Kamal Matthews – In 1979, a beloved mother and her 7-year-old son were brutally murdered in their Omaha home. It would take 46 years, a DNA match, and forensic genealogy to finally bring a suspect to justice. 🔹 Diane Peterson – A young high school teacher stabbed to death in her classroom in 1978. Nearly 47 years later, a long-silent witness stepped forward, confirming suspicions and finally revealing her killer’s name. 🔹 Phyllis “Jeanie” Bailer – A 26-year-old mother found murdered in a ditch off an Indiana highway in 1972. Her 3-year-old daughter survived the night beside her. After more than 50 years, DNA and genetic genealogy identified the man responsible. 🔹 Sheri, Garett, and Gavin Coleman – A picture-perfect family, torn apart by betrayal and murder. Sheri and her two sons were found strangled in their home in 2009. Her husband, Chris Coleman, orchestrated the killings to start a new life—with someone else.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/80334e05
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

The Murder Case of Sandra Birchmore #434

🕒 Case Lineup 🔹 Sandra Birchmore – Groomed, isolated, and ultimately silenced. Sandra Birchmore was born May 13, 1997, and endured a childhood marked by loss and instability. At 12, she joined Stoughton PD’s Youth Explorers Program, where she was groomed by Officer Matthew Farwell. Their relationship escalated into years of abuse, manipulation, and control. In 2020, Sandra became pregnant and believed the baby was Farwell’s. She named the child Anaya Grace and prepared a nursery, clinging to hope he’d accept them. But Farwell distanced himself, mocked her, and escalated control. On February 1, 2021, he visited her apartment. Thirty minutes later, she was dead. Her body was found days later with signs of strangulation—yet authorities ruled it suicide. Evidence—over 35,000 texts and journal entries—was hidden until the FBI stepped in. In 2024, Farwell was charged with Sandra’s murder. DNA showed he wasn’t the baby’s father, making his actions even more horrifying. Three officers, including Farwell’s twin and former Deputy Chief Devine, were found to have had sexual relationships with Sandra. The same officers also had roles in the controversial Karen Read case—exposing deeper systemic failures. DA Michael Morrissey, criticized for conflicts of interest, refused to recuse himself from either case. Independent journalists like Microdots and Turtleboy helped shine a light on Sandra’s story, connecting it to broader corruption. Her name was banned during Karen Read’s trial, but supporters refused to stay silent. A 2021 study shows homicide is the leading cause of death for pregnant women in the U.S.—most often by partners. Sandra deserved protection, not betrayal. Justice for Sandra. Justice for Anaya Grace.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/bc617090
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 Solved True Crime Cases #433

🕒 Case Lineup: 🔹 Ashling Murphy – A 23-year-old teacher and beloved musician was murdered during an afternoon jog in Tullamore, Ireland. Her killer was convicted, but the case continues with new charges against his family for interfering with the investigation. 🔹 Jamie Rose Bolin – A bright and independent 10-year-old girl from Purcell, Oklahoma, was brutally murdered by a neighbor with dark fantasies. Her killer was executed in 2024 after years of legal battles. 🔹 Kania Brunson – A 20-year-old Milwaukee cosmetology student was murdered by a controlling older man she had been trying to leave. Her brutal death and the failed alibi of the killer’s wife shocked the community. 🔹 Lexis Kaye Roberts – A 12-year-old girl was held captive and murdered by Thomas Sanders after witnessing the murder of her mother. Though sentenced to death, Sanders’ punishment was commuted—until Louisiana reopened the case in pursuit of true justice. 🔹 Xin Yang – A 22-year-old international student at Virginia Tech was decapitated by a fellow Chinese classmate who had become obsessively infatuated with her. Her brutal murder stunned a campus still healing from a previous mass tragedy.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/1e2c83dd
 
Support the show
Subscribe to my YouTube channel (It's free):✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

5 True Crime Cases Still Unsolved in 2025 #432

🕒 Case Lineup – 5 Chilling True Crime Stories Each one a haunting mystery that demands answers. 🔹 Daniel “DJ” Reed Smith – A 29-year-old father and carpenter found dead on railroad tracks in South Carolina. Initially ruled an accident, a 2024 lawsuit alleges he was murdered and his body staged in a cover-up. 🔹 The Dardeen Family Murders – In 1987, Keith and Elaine Dardeen, their son Peter, and newborn daughter were brutally murdered in their Illinois trailer. Despite a bizarre false confession from a serial killer, the case remains unsolved and as disturbing as ever. 🔹 Kimber Leanne Lucas – A 25-year-old pregnant woman trying to escape life on the streets was found stabbed to death in Halifax in 1994. Despite DNA and suspects, her case remains unsolved and is believed to be linked to other murders. 🔹 Melissa Ann Trumpy – A 37-year-old mother of three vanished after visiting her abusive boyfriend in Illinois. Her rented truck was later found abandoned, but Melissa has never been seen again. As of June 2025, she remains missing. 🔹 Terri Marie Howell – A 24-year-old mother was found murdered and set on fire in a rural Kentucky farmhouse in 1980. Despite early missteps and missing evidence, her family continues to push for answers in this long-unsolved case.
 
📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/8bd0ce5d
 
Support the show
Subscribe:✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8